The results of the war in the Caucasus

The biggest mosque in Europe, "Heart of Chechnya" named after Akhmad Kadyrov, designed for 10,000 people, 2008.

The official version - that the friendship has won. Insidious enemy partially repented and become white and fluffy, and some became heroes of Russia.
And now peace in Chechnya, and the sheer beauty of the construction of the resort area.

However, a purely formal features, allowing to determine the winner in the war. Consider them:

1. FIELD OF BATTLE IS FOR THE WINNER.
In Chechnya, - local government and local orders. The situation where the federal government does not control.

2. loser pays indemnities.
Chechnya - superdotatsionny region. In addition to direct infusions of residents, for example, do not pay for electricity and water. The official explanation - that because of the high unemployment rate the inhabitants can not pay. The entire year just delighted in the TV news reports about how at the dodgers in Russia cut off electricity and water supply. Despite the fact that in many places the work is also very bad.

3. The soldiers and officers of the losing side judge for war crimes.
Everyone knows the high-profile trial of the officers of the Russian troops who fought in Chechnya.

4. WHAT committed by soldiers and officers of the winning party in the conduct of hostilities in REALIZATION OF ORDERS crimes are not considered.
For militants from Chechnya regularly declared an amnesty, but troops of the Russian side, they do not apply.
The conflict in Chechnya began with the fact that the Chechens are killed partly, partly robbed and expelled Russian whom there were almost as many as there are Chechens. These events are legally not considered them try not to remember.

5. The citizens of the country to win the war and occupy others have immunity from prosecution from the losers.
It was a lot of cases, when the "Chechen police" came to a different region, someone were shot and left quietly.
In the case of the Chechen conflict, addresses in other regions, with the locals Chechens always punished a lot softer. About how conflicts can understand Russian Chechens in Chechnya, and I will not write.

Thus, when viewed objectively that case, the war in Chechnya, and Russia won Chechnya.



Now consider the second question - who exactly she won.

She won Russian? No, from the point of view of the Russian war was not popular, and led her not the Russian people and the government and the state.

The hostilities was not the people, and military units, and only some of them. True folk it would be if the Russian decided that they are at war with Chechnya. But then the war came to a very different: there would be a record volunteer militia, the guerrilla groups in the temporarily occupied territory ... And if the Russian began to fight it as a nation, they would have won. So back to the beginning - not the war led the Russian people (I say that in Russian include everything a sense of unity, regardless of the blood), and the Russian government. And it lost.

And since all the offices and presidents in democratic Russia are the successors of each other, from this we conclude that the government, which is now in Russia - it is a native local administration of the occupation regime. If we consider the government from this point of view, its action is understandable and logical. And the fact that they derive from all Russian money and resources that can. And the fact that they are defeatist foreign policy. And the fact that they are absolutely not involved in the development of the country. And much more.

In this regard, by the way, it becomes clear why the Chechen Republic and provides virtually 100% of the vote for the ruling party and the respective president.

What is the fate of occupied Russia? As in all countries - the period of the occupation comes to an end sooner or later, and especially long-term, he never.



What is the fate of the occupation government? She always unenviable always develops in one scenario. The puppet government in power, is trying to flirt with Westerners, giving them concessions at the expense of the country and trying to achieve a personal arrangement. Westerners are smiling and swinging them on the cheek. Then the puppet government earned overwork denyuzhku makes feet to the west. Then suddenly Westerners see and discover that denyuzhku been acquired by unrighteousness. The type of blood diamonds. Money and other property confiscated in their favor, runaway rulers and families are beginning to drive ...

What could be the end of the occupation regime? Often it ends in good faith by the victor. Defeat the enemy, destroyed the regime - went home. In the case of Chechnya, is, you know, will not pass. The second option - the uprising against the occupiers. What was most colonies. Or, in the above coordinate system - a popular uprising and people's war Russian (widely understood) against the occupation government.



Take the official view that the military conflict in Chechnya has overcome the world, friendship, and all these contributions and preferences Chechens occur solely due to the fact that we are Russian, so good. More precisely - we have a good government. In relation to public property. It might take him a whole, but instead a portion of the Chechens.

But the official point of view, contrary to the behavior of the Chechens who behave in Russia as the winners in the occupied country. And the behavior of the government, which is the behavior of the Chechens did not repress.

I understand that the majority of people in Russia it is already fed up, and to assist the authorities they do not believe.

And the development of the country, I see only two:

1. The Government starts to perform their duties by providing all citizens the same rights and obligations, regardless of their nationality. In particular - the fact that the crimes and violation of the procedure must meet all the same.

2. The government is trying to stifle the growing tension force measures and campaigns against the "terrible Russian nationalism." It ends all people's war, with all its consequences.

Option №1 seems much more preferable. Option №2 - more likely.