436
The diagnosis of the Moscow police
The former head of the Moscow Criminal Investigation Colonel Alexander Trushkin in an interview with "Novaya Gazeta" - about what's really going on in the Moscow police.
- Let's start with the main thing: why left the Moore's two weeks before you had to assign a rank of general? (We have known each other, and "you", but there are rules of etiquette newspaper - because I will vykat.) In addition, many Muscovites tied it with you hope for real reform of the Metropolitan Police ...
- I'm not chasing the rank of general. I walked away from the insanity that is there now formed. In other words, because the pursuit of statistics, "sticks", "jackdaws" no job. It was even worse than before: tons of papers, endless meetings, and no one to work on the ground. I will not participate in this "cane" system and never participated. Although I know that it is possible to manipulate these inflated numbers without leaving the office, but for me in the first place - the real solution of crimes, not "stick" and how beautiful the management report.
- At a recent board of total capital cupola Kolokoltsov Minister said that Moscow police expect due diligence. He also expressed concern about the manipulation of statistics and an increase in citizen complaints about police failure to take statements. They were told, and I quote: "I warn you again: stop the practice of transferring staff from the regions where they worked." This stone in the garden of the Metropolitan Police chief Anatoly Yakunin, he also came from the Eagles and brought his fellow countrymen?
- Minister knows better. I think Vladimir saw in Moscow did not go in the direction. He has always called for a lively work, fought for the disclosure of specific crimes for interaction between services. And now, as I said, there is a complete torn, and the work on statistics. You see, visiting officials, who are appointed to high positions, mostly do not understand the specifics of Moscow. They used to be small areas where everyone knows each other, while in Moscow around every corner - surprises. For example, in any field is already known who goes to a particular restaurant, what group and what contingent. And when it starts a fight or shooting, it can always be calculated. And in the capital goes to restaurants anyone, anytime. And when they begin to ask, "Why do you not know that the restaurant will be a fight or shooting?" - How to respond? This is insanity and debilizm ...
- Let's go back to 2012, when you led Moore. What immediately confused?
- When I became sort by department, then I realized that the leaders rather weak. I had to clean and change. Who wanted to change and learn, he was ...
- What do you mean - weak leader?
- Well, they do not know where their employees what they are doing and with whom to meet. They do not know and do not even read the material things that they are. I had to call the rank and file that they reported to me, because the leaders did not penetrate to the essence and not interested. Everything was left to chance. At six o'clock all run home, with people on the ground no one wants to work.
Once I decided to check how many night operatives involved? It turned out the whole of Moscow - 15 people.
- Are you trying to buy?
- I tried to buy before. Directly - no, and approaches through subordinates searched. I've heard that "obnalschiki" (members of criminal schemes to cash in criminal and corrupt capital. - Ed.) Offered by some brokers 500 thousand. Dollars a month. The type that I did not touch them. The operating materials have wiretaps of their conversations, where one says to another: "Trushkin useless" bring ", he is an honest moron." Then after some staff persons organizing illegal migration - offers millions. And I answered them - a criminal case. As a result, some employees have expelled or imprisoned.
- A traitor in the Moscow police a lot?
- When planning activities are often faced with the fact that the information went, and so much frustrated.
- Sell information to criminals?
- Yes. Well, for example, created a big problem for the department hijacking vehicles (7th department of Murano. - Ed.). It is no secret that police "roof" of criminal groups. Not every little thing, and serious organized crime groups who steal expensive cars. I found out that none of these criminal groups in Moscow has been delayed. There were no developments to sit all members of organized crime groups. To create the appearance of work and delayed every little thing. Channels withdrawal machines from Moscow are not identified and do not overlap, and expensive foreign cars continued to steal. I'm on the audit of the State Department brought several people. But then they were without any checks took GUUR (General Directorate of Criminal Investigation Department of the Interior Ministry. - Ed.), And they continue to continue to "fight" with the hijackers. Though everyone knows that these officers have links with criminal organizations.
- What, in your opinion, the level of corruption in the Metropolitan Police?
- Big. All prostitution is under police. Those shooting galleries ...
- I told you straight in the eye say some executives, the "roof" of prostitution: "What are you a policeman? You - a pimp! »
- I just told them that I think about them. I used to work openly, without dark schemes. For this they told me ... well, very much like. (Laughs.)
Come on. Let's take the situation with underground car services in the Moscow region, where dismantle stolen foreign cars. 80% of stolen cars of the middle class is under disassembly. None of these sweatshops touches. You see no one!
When I began to raise these questions, the ruler of the district began to direct in garages precinct. Type: checked and drawn up. I tell them: "Are you stunned? Perform operational activities and find out when they come to dismantle stolen cars and catch the thieves. Make sure the entire chain, identify the auto shops where stolen parts are delivered. " And they look at me like I was crazy, and say, "Precinct no violations found." This is how to understand?
Another interesting point: I found out that in Moscow operate about 15 exchange offices, where illegally cashing black cash. Bags of money are intact. Clients of such firms are constantly robbing and shooting, beatings were even murder. Criminals observers working women with children, the elderly, and all reported: who entered with a bag, etc. I ask a question ruler of the district, "Why no one can cover these offices? Let's remove them, criminals will look for new points and in the end, will light up. " And they say: "There is no legitimate reason to close the office." How is it - no? And lead a normal operational work? I wrote a letter to the chief of the capital's central board, but obnalnye office is still working. I believe that there is corruption - there. And I know that the "do not touch" obnalschiki offer half a million dollars a month.
- And what happens in the regional criminal investigation department?
- I traveled a lot of units. Conclusion: always a very low level. Employees do not know the most basic issues and do not work on the ground. I'm not talking about the operational component. Experience no no, and investigators are not trying to dial it. And all the work aims to ensure that the day is necessary to make a summary. So they are engaged in all sorts planted, fraud. No checks, such as those with delayed drug. And I'm confident that it's basically - planted. Either operatives negotiate with drug addicts, and they are under the control of selling drugs. Either arrange for the statistics with your friends. But no one fights dens. Even if you know the address of a brothel - did not develop, leaving only detain persons. Then give victory bulletins. All the work is going on.
I had to check each report and found that the staff of the Criminal Investigation Department are engaged in nonsense. Reached insanity: let's citizen detained for stealing a purse. A criminal case, the person is seated. I am calling the manager and ask: "Explain to me how your young employees arrested a pickpocket? After pickpockets - a narrow specialists and professionals? "And he was silent. I find out: a complete lie, toss!
- And then there are the examples?
- In one of the districts every month detained drug trafficker with a large party of heroin. I ask a question to the head of management: "What kind of talented people work in the department of criminal investigation department? Do they have good agents, "light" in this regard, the development of delivery channels of heroin? "I get the answer:" They do work there and we do not make known. " I am calling these employees and ask the same question. But they "went down the street and noticed a suspicious man. We checked out, and he found himself kilogram of heroin. " He began to check and find out that they have worked with the local drug addicts and caches calculated. Then set "pawnbroker" (member of the criminal group, to leave a party drug in the appointed place - Approx. Ed.), And under the guise of supposedly random passer detained. I tell them: "So it was necessary to develop a whole group of drug traffickers, due to work and schemes. In short, beautifully done. " And they are: "Why bother?" And so it turned out not once. I am calling the leaders of these operatives, and they are some kind of nonsense about the confidence of his subordinates.
As a result, we stopped to catch drug dealers and began to work on the "stick" and a summary. I've said a thousand times in the meetings: "Stop watching and" sticks "and fraud! After a criminal investigation at all rot! "It is useless, as the wall peas. Police officers do not want to work in a different way and can not - so it is easier: to throw or fake ...
- How is the interaction between services?
- Nobody wants to interact, and share all the "sticks" and reports. Comes to specific conflicts. For example, about who will give a summary of the first, and who will be on the first place. But it does not matter who first knocked on the door, or the offender's hand twisted, - the brains have to work! Because of these statistics - terrible fuss, which takes a lot of time. Recently, so-operatives shot at the Leningrad highway they were traveling on the detention is not fully prepared, with personal traumatic pistols, and about the actual operation of their leaders have learned after the shooting.
I also want to say about a bunch of "district-operative." This is - the most important moment in the Interior Ministry. The remaining units should assist in data and analytics. But in practice, operatives and district began grass-roots units, they all go. And while it is required of them and solve crimes and stupid statements. They are inundated with paper from headquarters: reporting, reporting, reporting ... When working with people? How to solve crimes?
- Appointed as the new head of the Moscow Criminal Investigation Department - Igor Zinoviev. What kind of person he is?
- I do not know ... (After a long pause) It is much softer than I ...
- October 20 you filed a report on the dismissal of Moore. As the minister reacted?
- He asked to stay and offered another post in the Interior Ministry. * I replied: "I can not constantly fight crime in their own ranks. My task - the fight against crime outside ».
- Life is starting from scratch, bribes do not take?
- Almost from scratch. Although I have a suggestion for the work. But government agencies, I do not go. I want to relax and stay for a family. Finally I became sleep.
- Surrendered mean?
- With a fright? No one gave up. Just in these conditions, my knowledge and experience are not necessary. Now employees work well and protect the people just do not want. They used to cheat, to engage in fraud. And I do not know ...
Source:
- Let's start with the main thing: why left the Moore's two weeks before you had to assign a rank of general? (We have known each other, and "you", but there are rules of etiquette newspaper - because I will vykat.) In addition, many Muscovites tied it with you hope for real reform of the Metropolitan Police ...
- I'm not chasing the rank of general. I walked away from the insanity that is there now formed. In other words, because the pursuit of statistics, "sticks", "jackdaws" no job. It was even worse than before: tons of papers, endless meetings, and no one to work on the ground. I will not participate in this "cane" system and never participated. Although I know that it is possible to manipulate these inflated numbers without leaving the office, but for me in the first place - the real solution of crimes, not "stick" and how beautiful the management report.
- At a recent board of total capital cupola Kolokoltsov Minister said that Moscow police expect due diligence. He also expressed concern about the manipulation of statistics and an increase in citizen complaints about police failure to take statements. They were told, and I quote: "I warn you again: stop the practice of transferring staff from the regions where they worked." This stone in the garden of the Metropolitan Police chief Anatoly Yakunin, he also came from the Eagles and brought his fellow countrymen?
- Minister knows better. I think Vladimir saw in Moscow did not go in the direction. He has always called for a lively work, fought for the disclosure of specific crimes for interaction between services. And now, as I said, there is a complete torn, and the work on statistics. You see, visiting officials, who are appointed to high positions, mostly do not understand the specifics of Moscow. They used to be small areas where everyone knows each other, while in Moscow around every corner - surprises. For example, in any field is already known who goes to a particular restaurant, what group and what contingent. And when it starts a fight or shooting, it can always be calculated. And in the capital goes to restaurants anyone, anytime. And when they begin to ask, "Why do you not know that the restaurant will be a fight or shooting?" - How to respond? This is insanity and debilizm ...
- Let's go back to 2012, when you led Moore. What immediately confused?
- When I became sort by department, then I realized that the leaders rather weak. I had to clean and change. Who wanted to change and learn, he was ...
- What do you mean - weak leader?
- Well, they do not know where their employees what they are doing and with whom to meet. They do not know and do not even read the material things that they are. I had to call the rank and file that they reported to me, because the leaders did not penetrate to the essence and not interested. Everything was left to chance. At six o'clock all run home, with people on the ground no one wants to work.
Once I decided to check how many night operatives involved? It turned out the whole of Moscow - 15 people.
- Are you trying to buy?
- I tried to buy before. Directly - no, and approaches through subordinates searched. I've heard that "obnalschiki" (members of criminal schemes to cash in criminal and corrupt capital. - Ed.) Offered by some brokers 500 thousand. Dollars a month. The type that I did not touch them. The operating materials have wiretaps of their conversations, where one says to another: "Trushkin useless" bring ", he is an honest moron." Then after some staff persons organizing illegal migration - offers millions. And I answered them - a criminal case. As a result, some employees have expelled or imprisoned.
- A traitor in the Moscow police a lot?
- When planning activities are often faced with the fact that the information went, and so much frustrated.
- Sell information to criminals?
- Yes. Well, for example, created a big problem for the department hijacking vehicles (7th department of Murano. - Ed.). It is no secret that police "roof" of criminal groups. Not every little thing, and serious organized crime groups who steal expensive cars. I found out that none of these criminal groups in Moscow has been delayed. There were no developments to sit all members of organized crime groups. To create the appearance of work and delayed every little thing. Channels withdrawal machines from Moscow are not identified and do not overlap, and expensive foreign cars continued to steal. I'm on the audit of the State Department brought several people. But then they were without any checks took GUUR (General Directorate of Criminal Investigation Department of the Interior Ministry. - Ed.), And they continue to continue to "fight" with the hijackers. Though everyone knows that these officers have links with criminal organizations.
- What, in your opinion, the level of corruption in the Metropolitan Police?
- Big. All prostitution is under police. Those shooting galleries ...
- I told you straight in the eye say some executives, the "roof" of prostitution: "What are you a policeman? You - a pimp! »
- I just told them that I think about them. I used to work openly, without dark schemes. For this they told me ... well, very much like. (Laughs.)
Come on. Let's take the situation with underground car services in the Moscow region, where dismantle stolen foreign cars. 80% of stolen cars of the middle class is under disassembly. None of these sweatshops touches. You see no one!
When I began to raise these questions, the ruler of the district began to direct in garages precinct. Type: checked and drawn up. I tell them: "Are you stunned? Perform operational activities and find out when they come to dismantle stolen cars and catch the thieves. Make sure the entire chain, identify the auto shops where stolen parts are delivered. " And they look at me like I was crazy, and say, "Precinct no violations found." This is how to understand?
Another interesting point: I found out that in Moscow operate about 15 exchange offices, where illegally cashing black cash. Bags of money are intact. Clients of such firms are constantly robbing and shooting, beatings were even murder. Criminals observers working women with children, the elderly, and all reported: who entered with a bag, etc. I ask a question ruler of the district, "Why no one can cover these offices? Let's remove them, criminals will look for new points and in the end, will light up. " And they say: "There is no legitimate reason to close the office." How is it - no? And lead a normal operational work? I wrote a letter to the chief of the capital's central board, but obnalnye office is still working. I believe that there is corruption - there. And I know that the "do not touch" obnalschiki offer half a million dollars a month.
- And what happens in the regional criminal investigation department?
- I traveled a lot of units. Conclusion: always a very low level. Employees do not know the most basic issues and do not work on the ground. I'm not talking about the operational component. Experience no no, and investigators are not trying to dial it. And all the work aims to ensure that the day is necessary to make a summary. So they are engaged in all sorts planted, fraud. No checks, such as those with delayed drug. And I'm confident that it's basically - planted. Either operatives negotiate with drug addicts, and they are under the control of selling drugs. Either arrange for the statistics with your friends. But no one fights dens. Even if you know the address of a brothel - did not develop, leaving only detain persons. Then give victory bulletins. All the work is going on.
I had to check each report and found that the staff of the Criminal Investigation Department are engaged in nonsense. Reached insanity: let's citizen detained for stealing a purse. A criminal case, the person is seated. I am calling the manager and ask: "Explain to me how your young employees arrested a pickpocket? After pickpockets - a narrow specialists and professionals? "And he was silent. I find out: a complete lie, toss!
- And then there are the examples?
- In one of the districts every month detained drug trafficker with a large party of heroin. I ask a question to the head of management: "What kind of talented people work in the department of criminal investigation department? Do they have good agents, "light" in this regard, the development of delivery channels of heroin? "I get the answer:" They do work there and we do not make known. " I am calling these employees and ask the same question. But they "went down the street and noticed a suspicious man. We checked out, and he found himself kilogram of heroin. " He began to check and find out that they have worked with the local drug addicts and caches calculated. Then set "pawnbroker" (member of the criminal group, to leave a party drug in the appointed place - Approx. Ed.), And under the guise of supposedly random passer detained. I tell them: "So it was necessary to develop a whole group of drug traffickers, due to work and schemes. In short, beautifully done. " And they are: "Why bother?" And so it turned out not once. I am calling the leaders of these operatives, and they are some kind of nonsense about the confidence of his subordinates.
As a result, we stopped to catch drug dealers and began to work on the "stick" and a summary. I've said a thousand times in the meetings: "Stop watching and" sticks "and fraud! After a criminal investigation at all rot! "It is useless, as the wall peas. Police officers do not want to work in a different way and can not - so it is easier: to throw or fake ...
- How is the interaction between services?
- Nobody wants to interact, and share all the "sticks" and reports. Comes to specific conflicts. For example, about who will give a summary of the first, and who will be on the first place. But it does not matter who first knocked on the door, or the offender's hand twisted, - the brains have to work! Because of these statistics - terrible fuss, which takes a lot of time. Recently, so-operatives shot at the Leningrad highway they were traveling on the detention is not fully prepared, with personal traumatic pistols, and about the actual operation of their leaders have learned after the shooting.
I also want to say about a bunch of "district-operative." This is - the most important moment in the Interior Ministry. The remaining units should assist in data and analytics. But in practice, operatives and district began grass-roots units, they all go. And while it is required of them and solve crimes and stupid statements. They are inundated with paper from headquarters: reporting, reporting, reporting ... When working with people? How to solve crimes?
- Appointed as the new head of the Moscow Criminal Investigation Department - Igor Zinoviev. What kind of person he is?
- I do not know ... (After a long pause) It is much softer than I ...
- October 20 you filed a report on the dismissal of Moore. As the minister reacted?
- He asked to stay and offered another post in the Interior Ministry. * I replied: "I can not constantly fight crime in their own ranks. My task - the fight against crime outside ».
- Life is starting from scratch, bribes do not take?
- Almost from scratch. Although I have a suggestion for the work. But government agencies, I do not go. I want to relax and stay for a family. Finally I became sleep.
- Surrendered mean?
- With a fright? No one gave up. Just in these conditions, my knowledge and experience are not necessary. Now employees work well and protect the people just do not want. They used to cheat, to engage in fraud. And I do not know ...
Source:
